Cancer screening key issues. Why, who, which test do we use?

flickr.com/photos/ saturnino/ 1813270775

flickr.com/photos/ saturnino/ 1813270775

I recently read a great article demonstrating biases in the evaluation of screening tests. This is timely as last week I had a 75 year old female visibly upset that she no longer needed regular pap smears. She sighed and said “I guess no one cares if I die of cervical cancer.”

Cancers have different growth rates—which determines their potential to be detected by screening.   Also there are different characteristics of the disease. How fast does the cancer grow? Might the early-stage abnormalities regress on its own (without treatment)? Is there effective and acceptable treatment available? Are patients asymptomatic for a time during which detection and treatment will significantly reduce morbidity and mortality?  Do we have an effective screening test during the time that we could “catch” the problem in time to save their life?

What are the characteristics of the screening test?  Is the test sensitive enough to detect the disease during the asymptomatic period? Is the test specific enough to minimize false positives (a false positive test shows you have the disease, but indeed, you do not)?

What are the characteristics of the screened population? At what age is which screening test appropriate? (Should we test 10 year-olds for colon cancer?) Are patients willing to comply with subsequent tests and therapy if needed?

 

What does all this mean? Researchers are pooling studies to give us more insight into which tests should be performed in which patients. This is so that there is less chance of false positives (which leads to patient worry and further work ups) and more chance to find those most at risk. I think medical school ingrained in me a perpetual weighing of risks and benefits.

Advertisements

About drlesliegreenberg

I have been practicing as a family physician for over 20 years--as both an educator of physicians and clinician. From infancy to the elderly, I perform obstetrics and general medicine. I love my career and am passionate about my field of knowledge and my patients. Follow me on Facebook at Leslie Md Greenberg Medical Disclaimer The content of this website is provided for general informational purposes only and is not intended as, nor should it be considered a substitute for, professional medical advice. Do not use the information on this website for diagnosing or treating any medical or health condition. If you have or suspect you have a medical problem, promptly contact your professional healthcare provider.
This entry was posted in Cancer, General Medicine- Adults, Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.